• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
VIPS Commission

VIPS Commission

IAVCEI Commission on Volcanic and Igneous Plumbing Systems

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Committee Members
    • Equality, Diversity and Inclusion
      • EDI Resources
    • Documents and Reports
    • Constitution
    • Privacy Policy
  • Events
    • Conference Sessions
    • Field Trips
    • Guest Talks
    • Workshops
  • Blog
    • News
    • Book Reviews
    • Events
    • Interviews
    • New Research
    • Diaries
    • Outreach
  • Get In Touch
    • Join Us

Arc Volcanoes – Windows to the Underlying World of Magma Reservoirs

16 Sep 2021 by VIPS Commission
Early Career Researcher Stories Logo. Text on logo reads: An exclusive VIPS blog series showcasing the latest work of early-career researchers.

Jade Bowers – Boise State University, USA


Volcanoes are like gifts to geochemists… they take materials produced deep within the Earth and move them up towards the surface, where we can unravel their fascinating life stories!

Arc volcanoes are home to some of the Earth’s most explosive eruptions. They are also one of the main places where subduction zone research interacts with broader societal interests. The staging areas of these eruptions are the magma reservoirs which lay beneath them. Each eruption is influenced by the storage conditions and any open-system processes occurring within these staging areas, which ultimately controls what we observe and experience on the surface.

My research interests lie in understanding how magma is stored and the processes associated with volcanic eruptions. At Boise State University, I integrate petrology, geochemistry, thermodynamics and statistical modeling to investigate the processes that govern the magma reservoirs beneath arc volcanoes. Using the past to inform the future is an integral component of volcanic hazard mitigation. Understanding the storage conditions beneath a volcano that has already erupted, and identifying the processes occurring within the magma reservoir prior to eruption, plays a critical role in informing monitoring systems and hazard mitigation plans.

Two juvenile clasts from Sinabung Volcano. Clast A shows a medium-light grey host rock combined with a darker grey enclave towards the top. Clast B is the darker enclave.
Figure 1. Photographs of Sinabung Volcano May 2016 juvenile clasts (a) Hand sample image of representative host andesite with in-situ enclave. (b) Hand sample of a representative individual enclave.

Throughout my studies, I have been fortunate enough to work at two active arc volcanoes – Sinabung Volcano (Sumatra, Indonesia) and Llaima Volcano (Chile). As part of my Masters, I worked on the May 2016 Sinabung dome collapse, where I utilized in-situ mineral chemistry, thermobarometry, and statistical modeling to investigate the origin of magmatic enclaves observed within the lavas (Figure 1). Magmatic enclaves are typically recognized as clear evidence of magma mixing prior to an eruption. However, the preferred explanation of origin for these particular magmatic enclaves is varying degrees of disaggregation of the crystal-mush network laying beneath Sinabung Volcano (Bowers et al., submitted; Figure 2).

Figure 2. A possible model for the formation of enclaves and different glomerocrysts in the Sinabung magma based on textural observations and mineral-mineral thermobarometry. Some of the samples are disaggregates of a crystal mush deeper in the magma system while others are disaggregating from a shallow reservoir.

Llaima Volcano is now my natural laboratory, where I collected pyroclasts from extensive mafic ignimbrite exposures that were emplaced during a large volume explosive eruption (Figure 3). Mafic magmas are the most common type of magma to erupt on Earth, yet their low viscosity typically prevents mafic eruptions from being explosive. However, when they do occur, explosive mafic eruptions are among Earth’s most hazardous volcanic phenomena – the rapid rates of magma ascent mean early detection and warning systems are limited.

Three field photographs from Llaima Volcano. Photo A shows a brown/cream ignimbrite outcrop with a person for scale. Photo B shows a grey ignimbrite outcrop. Photo C shows a large (12cm long) dark grey pyroclast.
Figure 3. (a & b) Tens of meters-thick mafic ignimbrite (Curacautin) outcrops at Llaima Volcano, Chile. (c) Example of larger pyroclasts collected from the Curacautin ignimbrite. Pyroclasts range from <1 cm long to 12 cm long.

Like Annabelle Foster (Durham University) discussed in her ECR Story, volcanologists can use pyroclasts to investigate magma storage and ascent prior to eruptions. My colleagues at Boise State University use macrotextures of the pyroclasts and microtextures observed in the glass and bubble networks to investigate the processes occurring within the conduit after the initiation of an eruption (Marshall et al., under review; Valdivia et al., under review). In my research, I use the geochemistry of the pyroclasts and of the primary mineral phases and melt inclusions, combined with thermodynamic and statistical modeling, to understand the mafic magma’s storage conditions and identify potential open-system processes that may have led to the explosive eruption of an otherwise typically non-explosive mafic magma. An example of an open-system process is the introduction of new magma into a magma reservoir (e.g. magma mixing).

In many ways, the mineral phases present in the pyroclasts are the stars of the show. During their existence, minerals record information about the storage and open-system processes they undergo as they grow, in the form of compositionally varying zones of mineral growth. In this sense, these different zones act like tree rings recording the life story of the mineral. We can thus explore magmatic history through in-situ geochemical analysis of the mineral zones, from core to rim of the crystal (Figure 4). These mineral compositions are used as inputs into thermobarometric calculations – based on chemical equilibrium conditions, these calculations determine the pressure or temperature that the mineral crystallized at. This information can then be used to inform interpretations of the magma storage conditions where the crystal grew (e.g., converting crystallization pressure to the depth of crystallization; Figure 5).

In addition to changes in magma storage conditions, open-system processes can also result in the formation of new compositional crystal growth zones, in response to open-system processes changing the crystal’s changing environment. Magma mixing is recognized as reverse zoning in the crystal; normal zoning is the typical progression of a mineral’s composition as magma cools and crystallizes (e.g., decreases in compatible elements as they are depleted during crystallization).

A zoned plagioclase crystal, showing lighter and darker grey zones.
Figure 4. An example of a zoned plagioclase crystal. Darker zoning represents normal zoning. Brighter zones are reverse zoning. This crystal records at least two major events that impacted the composition of the plagioclase. Elemental profiles will distinguish between a closed or open-system (exchanging of mass) process.
An example of mineral-melt thermobarometry used to identify two major magma storage regions beneath Agung prior to the 1963 eruption.
Figure 5. An example from Geiger et al. (2018) of mineral-melt thermobarometry calculated crystallization pressures interpreted as crystallization depths and used to identify two major magma storage regions beneath Agung prior to the 1963 eruption.

Later, the compositional profile of the outermost zone boundary can be used to calculate the time between zone crystallization and eruption using a geological technique known as diffusion chronometry. We then use this timing information to determine if these perturbations resulted in eruption initiation.

The Llaima project is in its early stages of geochemical characterization and mineral grain mount preparation. We are looking for evidence of conditions or processes that indicate why this mafic center, Llaima Volcano, erupted explosively. We hope that there will be many mineral compositions and zoning profiles to share soon, so keep an eye out!


A photograph of Jade holding her thumbs up in the field. A volcano can be seen in the back ground of the image.

Jade Bowers (jadebowers@u.boisestate.edu) is a Ph.D. candidate at Boise State University, USA. During her masters, Jade investigated the texture and crystal chemical stratigraphy of the lavas and intermingled mafic enclaves from the May 16th 2016 Sinabung Volcano dome collapse. Her research focused on magma storage and dynamics within arc volcanoes using multi-pronged petrologic forensic studies to understand how the magma is assembled, evolves, and is mobilized to the surface.

Jade now focuses on investigating the transcrustal conditions that led to the large, mafic eruption of the Curacautin ignimbrite at Llaima Volcano, Chile, with a particular interest in understanding why all mafic centers do not produce explosive Plinian eruptions.

Get in contact with Jade via email and connect via Twitter @volcanophile and Instagram @volcanophile.


Would you like to be featured on our blog?

We’re on the hunt for fellow VIPS enthusiasts to share their stories, whether you’re a student, an early career researcher (ECR) or more experienced researcher – we want to hear from you!

Do you have a new paper to tell the world about? Or have you been involved in some exciting fieldwork recently? Get in touch at info@vipscommission.org to tell us what’s going on in your field of VIPS.

Share this post:

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Share on E-mail
Category: New Research

Please give us your email address below to become a member and to receive our latest news direct to your inbox

Previous Post:What pathways for ascending magma? Behind the scenes with Eleonora Rivalta
Next Post:Deciphering Ore Deposits in Colombia and Mexico with the VIPS Website TeamVIPS Logo in the colour red

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Us

The main goal of the new IAVCEI commission on VIPS is to provide a forum for VIPS research beyond disciplinary or methodological boundaries to foster an integrated understanding of magma transport and storage in the crust.

Connect with Us

Got any great volcano puns? Have comments/compliments about our blog?

info@vipscommission.org

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Become a Member

Our Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2023 · VIPS Commission · Website by Callia Web